Before and After is a fun game to play between cast members. It’s hard to play with listeners because it’s a little complicated to explain, and takes too long for a contestant to figure out how to interact.
However, if played properly among the cast, it’s a terrific play along game.
You may wonder how it is a good game to play, if listeners aren’t involved. Remember, the value of games is to engage the listener, not just a contestant. In this game, the cast is the contestant playing against one another. If you really want to have a listener involved in playing, just have someone that picks who they think will win the game. If they guess correctly, they win.